18.5 C
Brasília
Sunday, November 22, 2026
HomeNationalPrivacy Concerns Rise as Bar Flags Woman as Public Safety Risk

Privacy Concerns Rise as Bar Flags Woman as Public Safety Risk

Date:

Related stories

Trump Claims Victory in Greenland Security Deal Amid NATO Tensions

Recently, President Donald Trump of the United States stated...

Tragic Death of Youngest Black Cambridge Professor Amid Plagiarism Claims

A sociologist from Britain, who stepped down from the...

Bridget Carleton Shines as Toronto Tempo Ends Losing Streak in Canada

Bridget Carleton, who grew up in Chatham, Ontario, never...

Ontario’s Moose Population Plummets: Experts Investigate Causes

Since the early 2000s, Ontario's moose population has experienced...

Nvidia’s CEO Resigns Amid Scandal, Shares Plummet 14% at Open

Nvidia's shares fell sharply on Thursday following a significant...

Concerns have been raised by privacy specialists following an incident in which a bar in Winnipeg flagged a woman as a nationwide public safety issue through its ID scanning system, resulting in her being refused entry to a venue during the Calgary Stampede in July.

Alexandra, a lawyer from Montreal, visited the Riverside bar in St. Vital on June 6, where a security personnel scanned her driver’s license using a Patronscan ID scanner at the entrance.

She indicated that she was not informed about the purpose of the scanning and was unaware that an event occurring later that night would lead to a flag that could potentially restrict her access to bars across Canada.

“This flag prevented me from entering an establishment in a completely different province without my awareness and without any clarity on how this flag was created,” Alexandra remarked.

She mentioned that she began to feel unwell while at the Winnipeg bar and hurried to the nearest restroom, fearing she might be sick. Someone knocked and asked her to leave, to which Alexandra requested additional time to recover. Ultimately, she exited without any further issues.

For her privacy, CBC News is only using Alexandra’s first name, as she is concerned about the professional fallout from sharing her experience.

Refused entry at Calgary Stampede venue

On July 9, she attempted to enter a venue at the Calgary Stampede that also utilized the Patronscan system and was denied access. The individual operating the scanner informed her that she had a “criminal record,” which she knew to be untrue.

Thinking it was a mistake, Alexandra tried to enter the same venue the following day but faced another denial, prompting her to seek clarification.

The staff member showed her a flag in their system linked to her ID, labeling her as a “public safety concern” with a “serious” severity level because she reportedly “entered the men’s bathroom and refused to leave,” specifically referring to the Riverside bar.

People walk up to a lineup at a security gate.

Alexandra states she was barred entry at a venue during the Calgary Stampede and was told she had a ‘criminal record’ following the incident at the Winnipeg bar. (James Young/CBC)

“I quickly understood that this was a data sharing issue, as how could a flag from a bar in Winnipeg appear at a venue in Alberta?” Alexandra expressed.

She captured a photo of the screen displaying this information and provided it to CBC.

“I found the existence of this specific flag to be quite outrageous,” she commented. “There are individuals who enter bars and commit assaults or instigate fights, engaging in all sorts of terrible behavior.”

Flag network utilized across North America

Alexandra soon discovered that the Winnipeg bar is part of Patronscan’s flag network, a mechanism used by the Calgary-based platform to notify other venues about problematic individuals.

This system eliminates the need for bars to contact one another directly to report troublesome patrons or to exchange incident reports, as noted on Patronscan’s website. The technology is in use throughout North America and other regions globally. The goal is to prevent dangerous individuals from entering venues.

The manager of the Riverside bar stated in an email to CBC News that after Alexandra reached out, they reviewed the situation and concluded it was an error, clarifying that it should have only been an internal flag. They have since removed the external flag associated with her record, the manager indicated.

WATCH | Woman denied entry to Calgary Stampede venue after incident at Winnipeg bar:

Lawyer labelled public safety concern after incident in Winnipeg bar

August 24|

Duration

2:44

A lawyer from Montreal was refused entry to a venue after her ID was scanned at the Calgary Stampede in July, due to being flagged as a public safety concern following an incident at a Winnipeg bar in June.

In response to her concerns, the bar has reviewed its staff training procedures regarding flagging and the protocols for sharing information with other establishments, as stated by the manager.

The manager emphasized that the bar takes privacy issues very seriously, but highlighted the crucial difference between the appropriate use of Patronscan for public safety and this “specific administrative mistake.”

Understanding data usage is crucial: experts

Experts interviewed by CBC noted that the incident brings to light several issues regarding the handling of individuals’ personal information when their ID is scanned at venues.

According to federal privacy laws for the private sector, organizations must inform individuals in a “meaningful way” about the reasons for collecting, using, or disclosing their personal data.

A woman with short hair and glasses wearing a dark blazer.

Teresa Scassa, the Canada Research Chair in Information Law at the University of Ottawa, emphasizes the need for individuals to be better informed about how their data can be utilized or shared when their ID is scanned. (CBC)

The legislation stipulates that an organization may only collect, use, or disclose personal information for purposes that a reasonable person would deem appropriate under the circumstances.

Teresa Scassa, who holds the Canada Research Chair in Information Law and Policy at the University of Ottawa, stated that individuals should be more inquisitive when handing over their identification for scanning.

A sign that says Patronscan and explains how the data collected will be used, shared and retained.

The sign beneath the Patronscan ID machine at the Riverside bar outlines how the personal information it collects will be utilized and shared. Alexandra received a photo of this sign from the bar’s management after she raised her concerns about the public flag. (Submitted by Alexandra)

“Is the data collection necessary? Is it appropriate for the situation? Does it overreach? How is the data managed? Is it secure? Who has access to it? These inquiries arise,” she explained.

A Patronscan representative stated in an email that when an ID is scanned, they gather details such as name, date of birth, gender, postal code, and expiry date to verify age. If nothing occurs that night, the record is erased within 21 days in Manitoba.

However, if an incident takes place, the venue can log a flag, and the data will be retained for a longer duration. In the case of serious incidents, a network flag can be created. These flags are visible to other Patronscan venues only when an ID is scanned.

Public flags enhance safety: BarWatch chair

The BarWatch program in Vancouver has been operational for over ten years, with its 46 participating bars and clubs utilizing Patronscan. The program allows bars to impose bans on individuals identified as gang members or deemed dangerous or harassing others throughout the network.

According to Curtis Robinson, the program’s chair and a former police officer, BarWatch has established protocols regarding when a public flag is assigned and collaborates with the Vancouver police.

A strict code of conduct is enforced for patrons, who risk being banned from the system for non-compliance. British Columbia’s privacy commissioner approved the program in 2009, provided that the information collected would be deleted within 24 hours if no incidents occurred.

“Individuals who are banned due to misconduct are not taken lightly. Such actions indicate unsafe behavior, and they are informed that, ‘Due to your actions, you are prohibited from entering here or any other BarWatch establishment,'” Robinson stated.

He added that individuals who prefer not to have their ID scanned can opt for bars that do not participate in BarWatch.

‘Undesirable to whom?’

At the Riverside, a Patronscan sign is located below eye level, under the ID scanning machine. Alexandra mentioned that she did not notice the sign during her visit.

The sign indicates that if someone is identified as violent or otherwise “undesirable” from a safety viewpoint, their name, date of birth, gender, postal code, and photo may be stored and distributed to other Patronscan locations.

Scassa pointed out that the sign raises numerous questions about whether it provides adequate notice.

For instance, she observed that it does not clarify that specific incidents will be communicated to other venues. In Alexandra’s situation, the Calgary Stampede venue accessed information about her incident in the men’s restroom at the Winnipeg bar.

Scassa also mentioned that it fails to state that the data is retained by a third party, and it remains unclear how many establishments might receive this information or their geographic scope.

Krystle Shore, an adjunct assistant professor at the University of Waterloo, researches the connections between surveillance technologies and societal issues. She stated that such notifications depend on individuals stopping to read the fine print and comprehending its implications.

“We venture into ambiguous territory when considering a sign positioned at a bar, situated below a stand where individuals might not be looking directly as they enter with a group of friends on a busy night,” Shore remarked.

woman with a cbc banner behind her

Krystle Shore, a privacy expert specializing in surveillance, notes that the process leading to someone’s information being shared is subjective and can have significant repercussions. (Aastha Shetty/CBC)

She indicated that the Patronscan disclosure sign raises several concerns, particularly regarding the term “undesirable.”

“What does ‘undesirable’ mean? Undesirable to whom? And in what context?” Shore questioned.

It is a mechanism dependent on one individual’s subjectivity, which can lead to significant consequences, she explained.

“When examining the surveillance of ‘undesirables,’ there exists a historical context of who specifically is targeted by such labeling,” Shore noted, adding that members of the 2SLGBTQ+ community have often been categorized as “undesirables.”

Bars required to display signage: Patronscan

A Patronscan spokesperson stated that signage is compulsory for clients and has been updated as required following various privacy commission evaluations.

The company will investigate any disputes regarding a flag, the spokesperson added.

Alexandra is currently preparing to file an official complaint with the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, which oversees compliance with the country’s privacy regulations.

Ann Cavoukian, former privacy commissioner of Ontario, condemned the incident as shocking and deemed it worthy of investigation by the commissioner.

“This individual was completely unaware that such actions were taking place and that her information was being utilized in this way afterward,” she expressed.

Former Ontario privacy commissioner Ann Cavoukian

Former Ontario privacy commissioner Ann Cavoukian asserts that the federal commissioner should investigate the episode, which she characterized as shocking. (CBC)

Alexandra shared her story to raise awareness among Canadians regarding the collection and sharing of their data by third parties.

“In an era of growing mass surveillance and the increasing use of AI for such purposes, I believe it is crucial for someone to speak out when they realize their rights are being infringed upon,” she concluded.

Latest stories